Both Northern (Hindustani) and Carnatic music traditions use rhythmic cycles (tala/taal), a principal first beat (sam), and mnemonic syllables (bols or solkattu) to express rhythm. However, the two systems diverge significantly in structure, terminology, and application. One of the primary differences lies in the role of jatis: in Carnatic music, jatis are foundational for defining the tala cycle, whereas in Hindustani music, the term jati refers to the number of notes in a raga (melodic scale).
Key Differences in Tala Systems
| Feature | Hindustani (Northern) Tala System | Carnatic Tala System |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Focus | Emphasizes improvisation within a flexible rhythmic cycle. | Focuses on structured compositions and mathematical precision in rhythm. |
| Core Units | Defined by the theka (basic drum pattern using bols). | Defined by angas (components like laghu, dhrutam, anudhrutam) and hand gestures (kriya). |
| Number of Talas | Fewer primary tals (about 10, e.g., Teental, Jhaptal, Rupak) with many variations. | Systematic framework of 7 basic talams combined with 5 jatis, creating 35 principal talams (with more complex variations). |
| Timekeeping | Tabla player is the primary timekeeper. | Time is often kept by the main musician or even by the audience using specific hand claps and waves, allowing more freedom for the mridangam player. |
| Cadence (Rhythmic Ending) | Rhythmic ending is called a tihai (a phrase repeated three times). | Rhythmic ending is called a teermaanam or korvai. |
| Tempo Terminology | Terms like vilambit (slow), madhya (medium), and drut (fast) for tempo. | Terms like vilambam, madhyamam, and dhritam for tempo. |
Role of Jatis in Both Systems
The term jati has distinct meanings and functions in Carnatic and Hindustani music, shaping their rhythmic structures in different ways.
In Carnatic Music:
-
Jati refers to the quantitative concept of specifying the number of beats or subdivisions in the laghu (component of tala). The five primary jatis are:
-
Tisra (3 beats)
-
Chatusra (4 beats)
-
Khanda (5 beats)
-
Misra (7 beats)
-
Sankeerna (9 beats)
These jatis are fundamental for the precise creation of tala cycles and play a critical role in mathematical precision within Carnatic rhythm. Jati is a structural tool that enables rhythmic variation, complexity, and improvisation, like nadai bhedam (changing the time signature while maintaining the underlying rhythm).
-
-
The use of jatis enables Carnatic music to have a highly defined, mathematical framework, where each tala cycle is constructed with a particular beat-count, facilitating elaborate rhythmic improvisation.
In Hindustani Music:
-
In Hindustani music, jati primarily refers to the classification of a raga based on the number of notes in its ascending (arohana) and descending (avarohana) scales. For example:
-
Audava (five notes)
-
Shadava (six notes)
-
Sampurna (seven notes)
While ancient texts mention the concept of rhythmic jatis, modern Hindustani music does not use the term in the same mathematical or systematic way as Carnatic music. In the Hindustani system, the focus is more on improvisation within a broader, more flexible rhythmic cycle (the theka), rather than strictly defined beat divisions like in the Carnatic system.
-
Summary
-
The Carnatic tala system relies heavily on jatis to define the structure and rhythmic subdivisions of tala cycles, with five primary jatis and their combinations creating a mathematically rich and precise rhythmic framework.
-
The Hindustani tala system, on the other hand, is based on theka (drum patterns) and allows for greater improvisational flexibility within a more limited number of core talas. The term jati in Hindustani music is used in relation to raga and does not directly impact the tala structure in the same systematic way.
In essence, the Carnatic system is highly structured and mathematical, with jatis being a central feature, while the Hindustani system offers more flexibility and improvisational freedom within a smaller set of standard talas.
No comments:
Post a Comment